PPinPinMe
Sign inGet started

Case Study: How a Handmade Tile Shop Found the Pinterest Pins That Led to Sample Kits—and Projects

A composite teardown of a handmade tile retailer that stopped celebrating saves and used sample, quote, and deposit data to find its highest-value Pinterest routes.

Vladyslav Budko· November 7, 2026· 11 min read

A handmade tile Pin can earn thousands of saves and still do very little for a tile business.

That was the central problem for this composite case study. The retailer had beautiful kitchen and bathroom imagery, growing Pinterest reach, and a steady trickle of traffic. But its owner could not answer a commercial question: which Pins were introducing people who would actually order samples, request a project quote, and place a deposit?

The answer was not the most-saved room photo.

The business—and the misleading baseline

The shop sold handmade wall tile nationwide. Its typical customer spent $24 to $36 on a tile sample kit, then made a larger backsplash, fireplace, or bathroom purchase after confirming color, finish, and quantity. The average project deposit was roughly $3,200.

During the prior 90 days, Pinterest looked healthy at first glance:

Metric 90-day baseline
Impressions 43,800
Saves 2,310
Outbound clicks 514
Tagged sample-kit orders 34
Quotes confidently tied to Pinterest 2
Deposits confidently tied to Pinterest 1

The owner was using saves as the primary success metric because that was the most visible number in Pinterest Analytics. But saves did not explain whether a shopper had a real project, knew their dimensions, or could afford handmade tile.

There was a second problem: Pinterest attribution broke after the first visit. A visitor might click a Pin, order samples four days later, call for a quote two weeks after that, and place a deposit through an invoice another month later. The shop could see some sample orders in its ecommerce platform, but not the full path from Pin to project.

The team reframed the goal from “get more Pinterest engagement” to:

Find the content routes that create the most project-ready tile shoppers per 100 outbound clicks.

The measurement repair came before the creative test

The shop did not start by making more Pins. First, it fixed the handoffs between Pinterest, the website, sample orders, and quotes.

A route-level UTM convention

Every newly published Pin received a UTM structure that made its purpose readable in analytics:

utm_source=pinterest
utm_medium=organic
utm_campaign=handmade_tile
utm_content=samplekit_backsplash_v1

The final value changed by route and creative version. Examples included:

  • measureguide_backsplash_v1
  • samplekit_kitchen_v2
  • productpin_glosswhite_v1
  • roominspo_mudroom_v1

This made it possible to compare Pinterest outbound clicks with website sessions, sample checkouts, quote forms, and later deposits. It also prevented the team from lumping every visitor under a single vague “Pinterest organic” bucket.

A better definition of a quote

Not every inquiry was counted as a success. A qualified tile quote needed four fields:

  1. Project type, such as kitchen backsplash or fireplace surround.
  2. Approximate square footage or dimensions.
  3. Desired timeline.
  4. A location the shop could ship to or serve.

A message saying “How much is this blue tile?” was useful sales context, but it was not a project-ready quote.

Joining sample behavior to later sales activity

The sample-kit checkout saved the UTM data with the order. The sales team could then match a later quote or invoice to the same customer email, while also asking a simple optional form question: “Where did you first find us?”

That second field mattered. UTMs are helpful, but they do not catch every delayed or cross-device visit. A customer may save a Pin on a phone, return through branded search on a laptop, and submit a quote form without the original campaign data.

The team used three attribution labels in its report:

  • Direct Pinterest: the Pinterest UTM appeared on the converting session.
  • Pinterest-assisted: the customer had a tagged Pinterest visit or sample order before converting through another channel.
  • Unconfirmed: no reliable source evidence was available.

This prevented Pinterest from getting credit for every sale while making its longer discovery role visible.

For a small publishing queue, the team kept the Pin ID, destination, UTM, publish date, and review date together in PinPinMe. The point was not more reporting software; it was being able to trace a promising Pin back to the actual page and creative that produced it.

Four routes went into the test

The retailer already had enough photography. What it lacked was intentional routes for different stages of tile selection.

Instead of testing random visual changes, it built four Pin groups around one core audience: homeowners planning a kitchen backsplash with handmade tile.

Route Example Pin promise Destination Primary outcome
Room inspiration “Warm white handmade tile kitchen backsplash ideas” Project gallery Engaged visit
Catalog product Pins “Gloss white handmade subway tile” Product collection Product-page depth and sample add-to-cart
Sample-first Pins “Choose 4 handmade tile samples for your backsplash” Tile sample kit page Sample order
Measurement-first Pins “How much tile do you need for a kitchen backsplash?” Coverage guide with sample CTA Qualified quote or sample order

The sample-first route addressed a low-risk decision: “I like this look, but I need to see it.”

The measurement-first route addressed a more advanced decision: “I have a project and need to plan it.” The guide included a simple measuring method, waste allowance notes, a plain-language explanation of variation in handmade tile, and a clear next step to order samples or request a quote.

The pages did not pretend to be a substitute for a professional installer or a detailed estimate. That restraint improved trust and kept the advice useful.

What the team held constant

To avoid a chaotic test, the team kept several things consistent for four weeks:

  • The same broad keyword family: handmade kitchen backsplash tile.
  • Similar vertical layout and brand treatment.
  • One dominant idea and one destination per Pin.
  • Four fresh creative variations per route.
  • No major sitewide promotional changes during the first review window.

It did not change the Pin title, image, CTA, landing page, and offer all at once. If everything changes, the resulting data cannot tell an operator what actually helped.

The 60-day readout changed the publishing priorities

Pinterest clicks were reviewed after 30 days, but quote and deposit outcomes were allowed a full 60 days from first click. That was still an early cohort for a considered home project, not a final lifetime-value study.

Here is the directional outcome from the initial test group:

Route Outbound clicks Sample-kit orders Qualified quotes Deposits within 60 days
Room inspiration 421 11 (2.6%) 1 (0.2%) 0
Catalog product Pins 294 15 (5.1%) 2 (0.7%) 1
Sample-first Pins 267 24 (9.0%) 5 (1.9%) 2
Measurement-first Pins 224 13 (5.8%) 7 (3.1%) 3

The room-inspiration Pins won on saves and outbound clicks. They were not useless: they revealed visual preferences and built a retargeting audience. But they were the weakest route to a defined commercial action.

The sample-first Pins produced the highest sample order rate. That mattered because samples were a meaningful leading indicator for this shop, especially when the order contained multiple finishes or colors rather than a single curiosity sample.

The measurement-first Pins had fewer clicks, yet produced the highest qualified quote rate and the most deposits. A shopper willing to measure a backsplash had usually moved beyond idea gathering.

This is the key distinction: the best Pinterest content was not necessarily the content with the biggest audience. It was the content that matched a decision the buyer was ready to make.

What changed after the test

The retailer did not delete its popular inspiration content. It changed its role.

It stopped scaling generic room imagery as a sales driver

The team continued to use attractive project photos, but paired them with a decision:

  • “What size tile works for a short backsplash?”
  • “Glossy vs. matte handmade tile in a low-light kitchen”
  • “Order samples before choosing a cream backsplash tile”

A beautiful kitchen became proof inside a useful Pin, rather than the entire message.

It made sample intent easier to recognize

The sample-kit landing page added short selection cues:

  • Choose up to four colors or finishes.
  • Include a project type in the order notes.
  • View current lead times before checkout.
  • Apply the sample credit to a qualifying full-tile order.

This helped the sales team distinguish a casual sample order from a shopper who was actively comparing materials for a project.

It added two reporting ratios

The weekly report no longer led with impressions or saves. It led with:

Qualified quotes per 100 Pinterest outbound clicks
Deposits per 100 Pinterest outbound clicks

The team also watched:

Sample-kit orders per 100 Pinterest outbound clicks
Sample-to-qualified-quote rate
Average days from Pinterest click to deposit

For an ecommerce catalog with a project-sized average order, sample revenue alone can be misleading. A sample kit may have slim margin or be credited back later. Its value is in whether it reliably advances the buyer toward a full order.

It gave each route a different job

The revised mix was practical:

  • 40% measurement and planning content for high-intent project traffic.
  • 30% sample-first content for shoppers choosing color and finish.
  • 20% product Pins for specific material searches.
  • 10% room inspiration for visual discovery and proof.

The percentages were not universal. They reflected what this shop learned from its own quote quality, sample behavior, and average project value.

The weekly tile report that kept the test honest

Every Friday, the owner reviewed a compact table rather than opening multiple dashboards without a question in mind.

Question Data source Decision it supports
Which Pins drove outbound clicks? Pinterest Analytics Diagnose creative and search relevance
Which routes drove engaged sessions? Web analytics and UTMs Check landing-page alignment
Which routes produced sample orders? Ecommerce orders Prioritize low-friction buyer actions
Which sample customers requested quotes? CRM or quote log Identify project intent
Which routes produced deposits after 30 to 60 days? Invoices and CRM Decide what to scale, revise, or pause

A route was not paused after one quiet week. Handmade tile is a slower purchase than an impulse accessory, and organic Pinterest distribution is uneven. The team looked for repeat patterns across a meaningful number of clicks and gave early Pins enough time to circulate.

It did, however, pause a Pin family when three conditions appeared together: low outbound click-through, a weak landing-page engagement rate, and no sample or quote activity after an agreed review period.

Transferable lessons for high-consideration ecommerce

A tile shop is specific, but the lessons apply to businesses selling products that require planning, fit confidence, samples, measurements, or approval from another decision-maker.

  1. Treat saves as a diagnostic, not a business outcome. A save may signal future value, but it cannot stand in for orders, qualified leads, or revenue.

  2. Use the next buyer decision as the Pin angle. For tile, that decision was often measuring the project or choosing samples. For another catalog, it may be compatibility, sizing, configuration, or delivery timing.

  3. Track the whole path, not just the first checkout. Pinterest attribution for considered purchases should account for direct visits, assisted conversions, and a realistic sales lag.

  4. Define a qualified conversion before looking at results. A quote is only valuable if it includes the information your sales team needs to act on it.

  5. Separate acquisition metrics from commercial metrics. Impressions, saves, and outbound clicks explain reach. Sample orders, quote quality, deposits, refunds, and margin explain business value.

  6. Scale routes, not one lucky Pin. Once measurement-first content proved valuable, the shop created related pages and Pins around fireplace surrounds, bathroom walls, and tile quantity planning.

The final lesson is simple: Pinterest analytics becomes useful when it helps an operator choose the next page to build, the next Pin family to publish, and the next low-value activity to stop. For this tile shop, the winning move was not posting more beautiful kitchens. It was making Pinterest measurable at the point where inspiration became a real project decision.

← All articles